Please enable javascript in your browser to view this site

Event debrief: INCA Summit 2026

Ofcom was accused of letting competition unravel to the benefit of BT given its recent decisions on Equinox, OTS and the TAR. 

A shift in the conversation from network rollout to take-up and sustainable competition

On 17 November 2026, the Independent Networks Cooperative Association (INCA) held its annual summit, bringing together altnets and suppliers from across the UK. The event was opened by Katie Crellin (Head of Regulation, Policy & Compliance, PXC), who offered a few home truths. She stated that for so long the conversation has been about attracting investment and deploying fibre, with altnets now reaching over 50% of premises. However, of that figure, 70% are overbuilt by at least one other fibre network – something Crellin considered is going to be “a problem” for driving take-up, building sustainable business models and fostering effective competition. She therefore argued that the conversation now needs to change, while altnets must also adapt to evolving market conditions and consumer expectations. In Crellin’s view, INCA’s role is not to pretend all altnets are the same, but instead to provide a strong collective voice to help the Government and Ofcom understand what is happening on the ground and to facilitate honest conversations that shape meaningful policy change.

Ofcom stated that evidence it has assessed does not point to Openreach strategically overbuilding altnets

The first panel echoed several of Crellin’s points, with Fiona Cayley (General Counsel, GoFibre) stating that “the hard bit is yet to come” and that it was right for industry and policymakers to question whether the current approach to commercial investment and public funding is the right one. According to Matt Warman (former MP and Minister of State, DCMS), the Government has two jobs: Attract investment where it is viable; and provide funding where it isn’t. He stated that it is “simply true” that a “big chunk” within government looks at broadband and thinks “job done”, but that is not the case. While recognising progress in fibre rollouts since 2019, Warman (now Board Member, UKAI and Senior Advisor, Alvarez & Marsal, among other roles) considered that barriers facing industry have changed, and that it may be appropriate for policy to evolve with them. However, he added that you cannot say the UK is at a pivotal moment “if you don’t pivot”, considering that the Government should be open to market developments and external factors, and “meet the moment”, working with Ofcom to determine what new support is needed.

For Tim Stranack (Regulatory & Trade Director, Community Fibre), a focus on urban areas is a missing piece of the UK’s policy jigsaw, stating that there are many tall tower blocks that are uneconomical for anyone, including Openreach, to connect, despite work with the Government over recent years to enable access. Amid suggestions of anti-competitive behaviour by Openreach (who was perhaps understandably absent from the panel and wider event), Ben Harries (Policy Director, Competition and Markets, Ofcom) stressed that “not all overbuild is anti-competitive”. Though the regulator has received complaints regarding strategic overbuild or practices that might discourage altnets to roll out in certain areas (and was looking at some now), Harries stated that the evidence assessed has not pointed to problems that would require intervention. He urged the audience not to “judge us by the outcome” nor to “call us slopey shouldered”. For Ofcom, the question is not whether Openreach may have adjusted its deployment plans over time, but why and whether it is economically rational in the sense that there is a business case for it to do so.

The Minister broadly gave a ‘politician’s answer’ to questions on the nexfibre/Netomnia and BT/TalkTalk deals

A keynote address from Ian Murray MP (Minister of State, DCMS) began on a light-hearted note, with a reference to his six-year-old son’s confusion that his father’s speech at an INCA conference was in no way related to Paddington Bear or “Darkest Peru”. Murray swiftly moved on though to matters at hand, stating that the Government’s ambition for growth in every postcode would mean “connectivity in every postcode”, underlining that the vital services being supplied by telecoms operators was about far more than “just delivering a product”. He outlined an expectation that Ofcom would (as Harries earlier described) continue to take an evidence-based approach to the sector, maintaining regulation where it remains necessary, adding that consolidation will be the path forwards for some altnets – something on which the Government will engage closely. Murray also promised legislation to tackle multi-dwelling unit (MDU) access issues “very, very, very soon”, which may have been music to Stranack’s ears.

During his subsequent Q&A with Kieran Smith (Telecoms and Tech Correspondent, FT), which was seen by a number of attendees as a bold move from the Minister four months in-role, Murray expressed concerns about the financial landscape for the altnet community, stating that the combination of low prices, high capital costs and big ambitions made for a significant challenge. Pressed on the Competition and Markets Authority’s (CMA) ongoing review of the proposed nexfibre/Netomnia transaction, Murray was noticeably careful with his words, merely stating that “CMA decisions are CMA decisions”, and that the arms-length body was focused on a very specific set of issues regarding the potential impact on competition. On the similarly contentious BT/TalkTalk acquisition, Murray stated that while the Government was aware of some rival bidders for the beleaguered TalkTalk, ultimately it was left with no choice but to step in (via a public interest intervention notice, or PIIN) to protect end users. Repeating on three occasions that the Government was in the middle of a “quasi-judicial process”, he would not offer a timeline on a decision from Lisa Nandy MP (Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport) on whether the deal should be referred to the CMA for a Phase 2 review, stating that she would need to take her time to make the right call. Murray was slightly more comfortable speaking to the possible future introduction of a Supplier of Last Report (SoLR) mechanism for telecoms, with the Government currently having few levers it could pull in the event of another TalkTalk-style failure. He considered that this kind of backstop is needed as telecoms is after all critical national infrastructure (CNI), adding that it is something other sectors already have. However, while such a process is being actively considered, Murray again provided no timeline for its implementation as it would rely on the adoption of primary legislation, which itself is dependent on “parliamentary capacity”.

Getting lean and generating cash would position altnets well for future consolidation

The subsequent discussion, held under Chatham House rules, began with the blunt statement that “everything’s sh*t, the whole thing’s sh*t”. The argument was that competition is “unravelling at a rate of knots”, with so much damage done to it in such a short space of time, tracing back to Ofcom’s decision not to prevent Openreach’s Equinox offers and to its recent Telecoms Access Review (TAR) statement. Much of this unfiltered commentary rang true for other panellists, who considered that altnets could either be “down in the dumps or get on with it”, for example by targeting greater cost efficiency – especially in instances where opex per customer is higher than ARPU. With “brutal” competition from the so-called incumbents at both the wholesale and retail levels driving price pressure and erosion, this requires altnets to take cost out of the business quickly. However, with expectations of sustained incumbent “aggression” over the next year at least, there were fears that the market could soon present an untenable situation for some altnets.

Given the need for the sector to reorganise towards cash generation after seeing a lot of money poured in, one panellist suggested that it was the time for altnets to “go to the gym, eat healthily and get into good shape” for the next phase of consolidation, anticipating many conversations about “who will dance” with whom. While other speakers also saw consolidation as an inevitability (especially in terms of paper or equity-based deals), it was highlighted that altnets may only pursue M&A where it means they would not get “infected with someone else’s disease”. The debate closed on a somewhat awkward note, with at least two of the five-strong panel considering that INCA may have not done enough to further the cause of its members. While the comments appeared to have been made and taken in good humour, recognising the difficulty in getting a plethora of altnets to speak with one voice, there was the feeling that they were being let down by the Government and Ofcom, with all policy and regulatory chips “falling in BT’s favour”.

One Touch Switch is positive for consumers, but panellists argued that it is being abused by larger operators

Elsewhere throughout the day, we heard several of the all too familiar remarks on pricing and switching – i.e. that price remains the single biggest priority in consumer decisionmaking, but that competing on this metric alone was a zero-sum game and that altnets should avoid a race to the bottom. During another Chatham House discussion, one panellist stated that while One Touch Switch (OTS) is great for consumers, it is resulting in a difficult experience for many altnets, which are competing with larger firms with deeper pockets on both an acquisition front and a retention front. Another claimed that OTS was introduced simply because Ofcom stated that it had to be done, but that it is a system that is being abused by larger operators, for example by calling up customers within minutes of receiving a notification in order to persuade them not to switch to altnets. The panellist added that even if the One Touch Switch Company (TOTSCo) thinks that those practices are within the rules, they may not be in the spirit of OTS.